Growing up, Japan was synonymous with the future. For my generation, the cultural impression came from anime series like Ghost in the Shell, Mobile Suit Gundam Wing, or Neon Genesis Evangelion. I think there were also leftover anxieties in the air from the 1980s about seemingly inevitable Japanese economic domination that you could see in movies like Rising Sun, Blade Runner, or even in the background of Die Hard. The vibe had material reinforcement from the seemingly endless series of gadgets and game systems that came out of Japan every year from companies like Sony and Nintendo. Japan was the land of robots and bullet trains. The predominance of cyberpunk and post-apocalyptic themes in Japanese scifi was mostly lost on 13-year-old me, as were the yellow-peril-coded worries about Japanese cars. To me, the Japanese gizmo-filled future looked bright if a little quirky.
My wife and I just returned from our first visit to Japan. It seems like every millennial with the time and money is making the pilgrimage to the place that provided their Saturday morning cartoons and first cars. Indeed, while we were there, we ran into tourists from all over the world, not just the expected Americans, Brits and Aussies, but also Italians, French, soooo many Germans, Mexicans, Brazilians, Israelis, large Chinese tour groups, and a surprising number of Russians and Turks. We were wowed by the same things anyone who’s been to Japan talks about: the fast and punctual trains, the clean streets, the smart toilets. But at the same time, I realized that Japan no longer occupied the imaginary Future with a capital F in the same way it did when I was growing up. For most people in the present moment, that position seems to belong to China. With its megacities and eye-watering investments into robotics and AI, China - or at least the social media image of it - appears to be a techno-optimist’s dream state. But that’s a topic for a different essay. Today I want to talk about what lessons Japan may still have for North America and Europe as we imagine our own futures.
Those lessons begin with how Japan lost its position as the image of the future. A lot of that has to do with Japan’s lost decades when years of high GDP and productivity growth came to an abrupt end with a stock market crash in 1990 in which the Nikkei lost 38% of its value. In a story familiar to many American readers, the crash was the result of rampant speculation fueled by low interest rates and lax oversight by banks when issuing loans. Since the early 1990s, Japan has seen persistently low growth despite repeated attempts at fiscal stimulus and quantitative easing. Wages in Japan today still haven’t recovered to their pre-crash levels. The result is that Japan has gone from an economic powerhouse rivaling the United States to an affordable vacation spot for the global north’s middle class.
At the street level, I could see some evidence of Japan’s prolonged stagnation. I saw far fewer EVs on the streets than I did in Sweden or Denmark. Japan’s legacy car industry is having the same difficulties adapting as American and German automakers are. The more upscale the restaurant we went to, the likelier it was to be entirely filled with foreigners. Even the famous Shinkansen trains we rode on were all at least 20 years old. The fact that no comparable high speed rail exists in the US is more a testament to America’s backwardness in infrastructure investment than it is to how advanced Japan is.
Japan and other East Asian in recent decades has been at the leading edge of social phenomena that would later come to other developed countries. For example, people often scoffed at Japanese tourists for taking pictures of absolutely everything, but after the proliferation of the smartphone, photographing and recording became commonplace. The problem of young people becoming shut-ins or hikikomori was originally recognized as a Japanese issue, but especially after the pandemic, many societies are dealing with young people increasingly withdrawing from social life. Dan Carlin applied Lionel Blue’s quote “Jews are just like everyone else” to the Japanese and I think he has a point. Beyond the tech-centric scifi visions of the future, we in the West should pay attention to what’s happening in Japanese society because they may be just a few steps ahead on the same trend line our societies are on.
Japan after the lost decades shows a possible future for many developed countries if they are unable to craft effective policies to navigate economic challenges today. The country has a debt to GDP ratio of over 200%. Its currency is devalued and unstable, relying on an intervention from the US Treasury to stop its decline. Despite Japan’s aging population and shrinking labor force, its strict immigration policies mean that foreign-born residents only make up a little over 3% of the total population. Japan’s main conservative party, which to the confusion of Americans is named the Liberal Democratic Party, has governed the country since 1955 with only two short periods out of power: from 1993-1994 and from 2009-2012.
Those familiar with the policy programs of MAGA and other far right populist movements may see where I’m going with this. Trump has repeatedly mused about devaluing the US dollar to boost American export competitiveness. His erratic trade policy moves actually did have the effect of lowering the dollar against most currencies. With tax cuts and defense budget increases, US debt is rapidly growing and currently sits at about 126% of GDP. The far right across the developed world wants to dramatically cut immigration even as birth rates have declined as has the ratio of workers to retirees. If the far right can attain durable power across the West, it could well end up looking a lot like Japan but likely without the bullet trains and heated toilet seats.